In the world of fashion, trainers have become more than just footwear—they’re a cultural statement. But as the UK trainer market continues to grow, a surprising truth emerges: the most popular trainers aren’t always the best. In fact, some of the trainers you see most often on the streets may actually be among the most criticised by those who wear them.
At Aisle 3, we’ve gone beyond the hype to uncover the real story behind the UK’s most popular trainers. We’ve analysed thousands of reviews and search trends to reveal a startling paradox: the trainers that everyone’s talking about might not be the ones you want to buy.
The Methodology: Cutting Through the Hype
How We Did It:
To get to the bottom of the UK’s trainer paradox, we conducted an in-depth analysis of the market’s most popular trainers. Here’s how we uncovered the truth behind the hottest styles:
1. Identifying the Top Trainers
We started by pinpointing the top 30 trainer brands in the UK, based on industry reports and market trends. From each brand, we selected the 15 most popular models, creating a comprehensive list of 450 trainers.
2. Analysing Search Trends
Next, we analysed Google search volumes to determine which trainers were truly capturing the public’s attention. We gathered data on multiple keyword variations for each model to ensure we accurately reflected their popularity.
3. Digging into Customer Reviews
Finally, we turned to the people who know these trainers best: the customers. We scoured reviews from major retailers like Amazon, JD Sports, Footlocker, and brand websites, focusing on both the praise and the complaints. By examining key themes in these reviews, we were able to identify the trainers that consistently impressed—or disappointed—their wearers.
The result? A clear picture of which trainers are worth your time and money, and which ones might leave you regretting your purchase.
Click here to see the detailed data and results from our research.
The Paradox Unveiled: Most Popular, Most Criticised
Despite the high search volumes and brand loyalty that some trainers enjoy, our analysis revealed a surprising disconnect between popularity and customer satisfaction. Here are the key findings that highlight this paradox:
The Most Popular Trainers Aren’t Always the Best
Nike Air Force 1
With over 280,000 monthly searches, the Nike Air Force 1 is undeniably popular. But popularity doesn’t always equate to quality. Our analysis showed us that 15% of reviewers criticised the quality, and 12% found them uncomfortable, suggesting that these much-loved trainers may not live up to their status.
Adidas Gazelle
Another iconic model, the Adidas Gazelle, also falls short in critical areas. While it’s a staple in many wardrobes, 13% of reviews pointed out that these trainers are too tight, and 12% cited poor quality, with some users even reporting discomfort and blisters.
New Balance 574
A popular model with a strong reputation, but our analysis revealed that 22% of reviews mentioned issues with durability, despite its comfort being praised by 38% of users.
Vans Old Skool
A classic design often seen as stylish, but 21% of reviews criticised its lack of comfort and poor support, making it a less-than-ideal choice for long wear.
The Trainers That Surprised Us
Skechers Go Walk
On the flip side, the Skechers Go Walk, while not as trendy or widely searched, excelled in comfort. A whopping 83% of reviews praised its comfort, making it a strong contender for those prioritising practicality over popularity.
Adidas Ultraboost
The Adidas Ultraboost also stood out for its all-round performance, earning high marks for comfort, style, and quality. Despite mixed feelings about other Adidas models, the Ultraboost proves that some trainers can offer both popularity and satisfaction.
Best and Worst: A Closer Look at the Top and Bottom Performers
In a market flooded with options, it’s not always easy to discern which trainers will truly deliver. Our analysis has pinpointed both the best and worst trainers based on customer feedback, helping you make a more informed choice.
Best All-Rounder Trainer: Nike Air Force 1
Despite some criticism, the Nike Air Force 1 emerges as the best all-rounder, balancing style, comfort, and durability. Here’s why it stands out:
- Style: With 15% of reviews saluting its stylish design, the Nike Air Force 1 remains a fashion staple. Its classic look has made it a favourite across generations.
- Quality: 23% of reviewers highlighted the good quality of this trainer, making it a reliable choice for those who value longevity.
- Comfort: While not without its detractors, 12% of reviews found the Air Force 1 to be comfortable, suitable for everyday wear.
Why Buy It?
The Nike Air Force 1 is the best choice for those looking for a versatile trainer that combines style with decent comfort and durability. Its high search volume and positive reviews make it a solid investment for a variety of occasions.
Worst Trainer to Buy: Adidas Gazelle
On the other end of the spectrum, the Adidas Gazelle ranks as the worst trainer based on our analysis. Here’s why:
- Too Tight: 13% of reviewers reported that the Adidas Gazelle was uncomfortably tight, often requiring a break-in period or even causing blisters.
- Poor Quality: 12% of reviews mentioned issues with the quality, particularly in terms of durability and construction.
- Discomfort: Another 12% of users found these trainers uncomfortable, with problems ranging from poor arch support to general discomfort after prolonged wear.
Why Avoid It?
The Adidas Gazelle might look good, but the data suggests it’s not the most comfortable or durable option out there. If you’re seeking a trainer that’s easy on your feet and built to last, you might want to consider other options.
Brand Showdown: Nike vs. Adidas – A Battle of Reputations
When it comes to trainers, Nike and Adidas are the two giants that dominate the market. But does brand loyalty align with customer satisfaction? Our analysis puts these two powerhouses head-to-head to reveal which brand truly delivers.
Nike: The Best Brand According to the Data
Nike’s dominance in the trainer market is no accident. Across multiple models, Nike consistently scored high in key areas that matter most to customers:
- Popularity: Nike’s trainers, such as the Air Force 1, consistently rank among the most searched, with strong brand recognition driving their market presence.
- Quality: Nike models like the Air Max 90 and Air VaporMax earned positive feedback for their durability and build quality, with 31% of reviews highlighting these traits.
- Comfort: While not every model is perfect, many of Nike’s offerings, such as the Air Zoom Pegasus, received praise for their comfort, with 42% of reviews specifically noting this feature.
Overall Verdict: Nike is the brand to beat when it comes to a well-rounded package of style, comfort, and durability. For consumers seeking a reliable and stylish option, Nike’s range offers some of the best choices on the market.
Adidas: The Worst Brand to Buy From
Despite its global popularity, Adidas didn’t fare as well in our analysis. Several of its most iconic models fell short in critical areas:
- Quality Issues: Models like the Adidas Gazelle and Ultraboost were frequently criticised for poor quality, with 12% of reviews mentioning problems like rapid wear and tear.
- Comfort Concerns: Comfort was another weak point for Adidas, with models like the Gazelle receiving numerous complaints about being too tight and causing discomfort.
- Inconsistent Performance: While some models, like the Ultraboost, performed well in our analysis, the overall brand performance was inconsistent, leading to mixed reviews across the board.
Overall Verdict: Adidas may have the name recognition, but when it comes to delivering consistent quality and comfort, the data suggests that other brands, particularly Nike, are better choices for most consumers.
Conclusion: Rethinking Your Next Trainer Purchase
Our in-depth analysis has uncovered a surprising truth: the most popular trainers aren’t always the best, and brand loyalty doesn’t always lead to satisfaction. While Nike emerges as the best all-rounder with consistently strong performances across its range, Adidas shows significant weaknesses that could leave customers disappointed.
Final Thought: Before making your next trainer purchase, consider what truly matters—comfort, quality, and durability. The data shows that by looking beyond the brand and focusing on customer feedback, you can make a smarter, more satisfying choice.
Ready to find the perfect trainer? Browse the best prices and trainers here.